Exploring supramolecular systems containing B-N frustrated Lewis pairs as revolutionary metal-free catalysts
For decades, the world of catalysis has been dominated by precious metals—rare, expensive, and often toxic elements like platinum, palladium, and rhodium. These metals power countless chemical reactions essential for creating pharmaceuticals, materials, and fuels. But what if we could replace them with abundant, inexpensive, and metal-free alternatives? This is no longer a theoretical question but a reality being forged in laboratories worldwide, thanks to a fascinating concept known as Frustrated Lewis Pairs (FLPs).
FLPs bypass the need for precious metals by using strategically hindered acid-base pairs that can't form stable bonds with each other, making them available to activate other molecules.
Since their discovery in 2006, FLPs have enabled numerous metal-free catalytic processes previously thought impossible.
The story begins with a simple chemical principle: acids and bases neutralize each other. Similarly, in molecular terms, a Lewis acid (electron-pair acceptor) and a Lewis base (electron-pair donor) will typically form a stable, unreactive bond. But in the mid-2000s, chemists made a crucial discovery. By strategically impeding this union—primarily by attaching bulky molecular groups that physically prevent the acid and base from connecting—they created "frustrated" pairs. These pairs, unable to quench their desire to react with each other, turn their attention to other molecules, becoming powerful metal-free catalysts for a host of chemical transformations 1 .
Among the most prominent stars in the FLP universe is tris(pentafluorophenyl)borane, a powerful Lewis acid often abbreviated as B(C6F5)3. When paired with the right base, it can perform one of chemistry's most sought-after tricks: cleanly splitting dihydrogen (H₂) without a metal in sight . This article explores the next frontier in this field—embedding these remarkable B-N pairs, particularly those involving boranes and triphenylamine derivatives, within sophisticated supramolecular architectures. By building nano-sized "cages" and porous frameworks around these catalysts, scientists are enhancing their power, stability, and selectivity, paving the way for a new generation of sustainable chemical technologies 1 .
Click to interact
To appreciate the genius of FLPs, it helps to imagine a molecular dance. A Lewis acid and a Lewis base are naturally attracted, like two dancers coming together for a final embrace that leaves them stationary. In a Frustrated Lewis Pair, these dancers are wearing overly large costumes—bulky molecular groups like mesityl (mes) or pentafluorophenyl rings—that prevent them from getting close enough for that final clasp.
This steric hindrance keeps them in a state of perpetual, reactive anticipation. Because they cannot form a classic bond with each other, their reactive sites remain open and primed to cooperatively attack a third molecule. The most celebrated example of this is the heterolytic cleavage of H₂ 1 . The Lewis base donates electron density to the H-H bond's σ* orbital, while the Lewis acid accepts electron density from the H-H σ orbital. This two-pronged attack polarizes and ultimately breaks the H-H bond, yielding a proton (H⁺) and a hydride (H⁻) that can then be transferred to other molecules 1 4 . This metal-free hydrogen activation, once thought to be impossible, is now a cornerstone of FLP chemistry.
Lewis acid and base approach but cannot bond due to steric hindrance.
The frustrated pair captures a small molecule like H₂ between them.
Acid and base work together to polarize and cleave the H-H bond.
The activated fragments are transferred to create new products.
While simple FLP molecules are powerful, embedding them within supramolecular systems—larger structures held together by non-covalent interactions—confers game-changing advantages 1 :
Supramolecular frameworks like Metal-Organic Frameworks (MOFs) and Covalent Organic Frameworks (COFs) possess well-defined pores and channels that steer reactions toward specific products.
Supramolecular structures provide a rigid platform to pre-organize acid and base components at an optimal distance, maximizing their cooperative effect 1 .
For years, the inner workings of FLPs held a mystery. How exactly do the Lewis acid and base, which are known to form a weak "encounter complex," orchestrate the activation of a molecule like H₂? The encounter complex was a postulated, weakly-bound species, but experimentally quantifying its formation and proving which specific orientation was responsible for reactivity remained a formidable challenge 4 .
In 2025, a team of researchers devised an elegant experiment to directly probe this active encounter complex. They focused on the classic FLP system of B(C6F5)3 (the Lewis acid) and P(mes)3 (a phosphine Lewis base) 4 .
Their methodology was as follows:
The experiment yielded a precise association constant of Kₐ = 2.52 M⁻¹ for the P(mes)3/B(C6F5)3 pair in toluene. This value corresponds to a very small, yet significant, negative free energy change (ΔG = –0.55 kcal mol⁻¹), confirming that the formation of the encounter complex is a slightly favorable, albeit weak, process 4 .
| Lewis Acid | Lewis Base | Solvent | Kₐ (M⁻¹) | ΔG (kcal mol⁻¹) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| B(C6F5)3 | P(mes)3 | Toluene | 2.52 ± 0.43 | –0.55 |
| Technique | Acronym | Application |
|---|---|---|
| UV-vis Spectroscopy | UV-vis | Quantifying encounter complex formation 4 |
| Nuclear Magnetic Resonance | NMR | Probing H···F interactions via HOESY 4 |
| Ion Mobility Mass Spectrometry | IM-MS | Characterizing large non-crystalline assemblies 3 |
| Cryogenic Electron Microscopy | Cryo-EM | Imaging self-assembled frameworks and polymers 3 |
Crucially, the researchers proposed that this spectroscopic signature was not just reporting on any random association between the acid and base. Computational studies had shown there are many possible orientations, stabilized by weak non-covalent interactions. They hypothesized that the charge-transfer band they monitored specifically required the alignment of the phosphine's lone pair (HOMO) with the borane's empty p-orbital (LUMO). This is the exact orientation required for small-molecule activation—the "active encounter complex" 4 .
Furthermore, they demonstrated a direct correlation: a higher concentration of this active encounter complex in solution led to a faster rate of H₂ activation. This provided a powerful new tool for the rational design of FLPs. By using this method to screen different acid/base combinations, chemists can now quantitatively predict and optimize catalytic activity based on the strength of their association 4 .
Creating these advanced catalytic systems requires a versatile portfolio of chemical building blocks. The table below details some of the essential components used in the construction and study of supramolecular FLP systems.
| Reagent / Material | Category | Primary Function | Example Use Case |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tris(pentafluorophenyl)borane (B(C6F5)3) | Lewis Acid | Strong, sterically hindered acid for FLP creation; p-type dopant | Core component for H₂ activation; used in MOF grafting 1 |
| Triphenylphosphine Derivatives (e.g., P(mes)3) | Lewis Base | Sterically hindered base that prevents adduct formation | Partner for B(C6F5)3 in seminal FLP studies and encounter complex analysis 4 |
| MIL-101(Cr), NU-1000 | Metal-Organic Framework (MOF) | Porous, crystalline support for immobilizing FLP components | Provides a rigid scaffold for post-synthetic grafting of Lewis acids/bases, improving recyclability 1 |
| Cyclodextrins (α, β, γ) | Supramolecular Host | Macrocyclic host for creating host-guest complexes | Improves solubility and stability of hydrophobic guests; used in commercial products for controlled release 2 |
| Cucurbit[n]urils | Supramolecular Host | Barrel-shaped macrocycle for strong guest binding | Used in odour control (Aqdot®) and explored as antiviral disinfectants 2 |
| Toluene / Benzene-d6 | Solvent | Inert, non-coordinating solvent for air-sensitive chemistry | Prevents decomposition of sensitive FLPs during synthesis and spectroscopic analysis 4 |
Supramolecular chemistry is already finding commercial applications in various industries:
Current research focuses on several key areas:
The journey of Frustrated Lewis Pairs from a laboratory curiosity to a cornerstone of metal-free catalysis is a testament to the power of fundamental chemical insight. By understanding and exploiting the principle of steric frustration, chemists have opened a new pathway to sustainable chemical synthesis. The subsequent integration of these reactive pairs into the meticulously ordered world of supramolecular chemistry—from the porous landscapes of MOFs to the defined cavities of macrocycles—is pushing the boundaries even further.
This synergy creates systems that are not only highly active but also selective, stable, and reusable. As research progresses, the focus will increasingly turn to refining these architectures for specific real-world applications, such as enantioselective drug synthesis 6 , environmental remediation of pollutants like PFAS 2 , and the development of new organic electronic materials . The challenge of scaling up production and ensuring long-term stability under industrial conditions remains, but the trajectory is clear 2 5 .
FLP-based systems represent a shift toward more sustainable chemical processes by reducing reliance on precious metals and enabling more efficient, selective transformations.
The field of supramolecular FLPs embodies a paradigm shift in chemistry, moving away from reliance on precious metals and toward intelligent design based on abundant main-group elements. It demonstrates that by embracing frustration and confinement, we can unlock powerful and elegant solutions to some of chemistry's most enduring challenges.